Third try is a charm for the PERFECT Crispy Baked Buffalo Wings recipe. I’ve found the secret ingredient for making buffalo wings ultra crispy in the oven. Hint: it is not baking powder. And it’s exactly why I’m re-posting these with a new and much-improved recipe!
It’s not that I mind eating the occasional deep fried food. Who doesn’t love french fries? I just don’t enjoy deep frying in my own kitchen; it’s too messy, too smelly, and then there’s disposing of the oil. Because of this aversion, I assumed that buffalo wings were only something to be ordered out.
But I’ve been enlightened; it’s possible to make super crispy, utterly delicious buffalo chicken wings in your oven! The secret ingredient? Plain cornstarch. Here me out.
My first attempt at making these went wrong, but it was my own fault. My friend Nagi posted these Crispy Oven Baked Chicken Wings with Honey Garlic Sauce (I made that sauce btw, and you have to try it. It’s awesome!). Then I came across Stephanie’s Crispy Oven Sriracha Buffalo Wings. They were both using a technique from the America’s Test Kitchen Meat Book; they coated the wings with baking powder before baking and, like magic, the wings came out crispy! I had to try it.
I tried it and they were HORRIBLE. It wasn’t until the next morning when I awoke with an awful taste in my mouth that I took another look at the recipe and realized that I’d used baking soda not baking powder. Whoops! Do not make the same mistake. After the baking soda flavor left my mouth, which was no less than a week, I decided to give the recipe another try. And the wings were very good, crispy on the outside; tender and flavorful on the inside.
But I have to make a confession: there was still a hint of metallic flavor from the baking powder that I didn’t care for, likely from the baking soda that is one of the ingredients. I learned that when I read the baking powder label, and the answer to the ultimate crispy wings was right there. The first ingredient in baking powder is, drumroll please…
Cornstarch.
When you coat chicken wings in plain cornstarch mixed with a little kosher salt before baking, you are rewarded with divinely crispy, ultra tasty buffalo wings with zero metallic flavor. They’re delicious on their own, but you can make them even better by bathing them in buttery homemade buffalo sauce and dipping them in my easy blue cheese dip.
How to Make Crispy Buffalo Wings
Step 1: Coat raw chicken wings in a mixture of cornstarch and kosher salt – 2 teaspoons of cornstarch and 1/2 teaspoon of kosher salt per pound.
Step 2: Bake coated wings on an oven-safe rack in a baking sheet for 30 minutes at 250°F, then 50 minutes at 425°F, rotating the pan halfway through cooking time.
Step 3: Coat in buffalo sauce and serve!
And for more spicy goodness, be sure to check out these TRULY Crispy Baked Buffalo Chicken Tenders – they’re amazing!
This may be the easiest and most delicious buffalo wing recipe ever! Serve these with celery and carrot sticks and blue cheese dip.
- 2 tablespoons cornstarch
- 1 1/2 teaspoons kosher salt
- 3 pounds chicken wings drumettes and flats separated (look for 'party wings' at the grocery store)
- 1/2 cup butter
- 2 cloves garlic minced
- 1/2 cup hot sauce such as Cholula Original or Frank's Red Hot
- 1/2 cup blue cheese crumbled
- 1 clove garlic minced
- 1 cup sour cream
- 1 teaspoon white vinegar
- salt and freshly ground black pepper to taste
-
Adjust oven racks so that one rack is in the upper-middle and one is in the lower-middle.
-
Preheat oven to 250°F.
-
Set an oven-safe wire rack into a baking sheet lined with foil or parchment paper. Spray wire rack with non-stick spray or brush with oil.
-
In a large bowl, whisk together cornstarch and kosher salt.
-
Pat chicken drumettes and flats dry with paper towels. Add to bowl with cornstarch mixture and toss to coat evenly. Arrange in a single layer on rack in baking sheet. Bake on lower-middle rack for 30 minutes.
-
Increase oven temperature to 425°F and move baking sheet to upper middle rack. Bake for 25 minutes. Rotate rack, front to back, and bake 25 minutes more until golden brown.
-
Meanwhile prepare buffalo sauce. Heat butter in a small saucepan over medium heat. When butter begins to melt, add minced garlic and stir. Cook and stir until butter is fully melted and garlic is fragrant; remove from heat. Whisk in hot sauce until smooth.
-
When wings are golden brown and crispy, remove them from oven and allow to rest on rack for 5 minutes. Then place wings in a large bowl and pour warm buffalo sauce over; gently stir to coat evenly. Transfer coated wings to platter and serve with blue cheese dip (recipe below).
-
Add blue cheese, garlic and sour cream to a medium bowl. Using the back of a fork, smash blue cheese crumbles into sour cream until flavors have melded. Stir in vinegar. Add salt and freshly ground black pepper to taste. Serve.
What a great idea, Marissa! I use cornstarch to get my oven-baked fries nice and crispy, but I’ve never tried baking buffalo wings. Like you, I assumed that was just something I needed to order out as we like our wings extra-crispy. I’ll have to try this…perfect timing for the Super Bowl coming up soon! Happy New Year, my friend, and thanks for sharing this deliciousness!
Now you have me wanting to try cornstarch on oven fries!! Thanks, David! And Happy New Year!
These wings look so tasty and juicy
thank you for shariing
Thank you!
New and improved, how could I not give them a try. 🙂
I’d love to whip you up a batch myself, Karen!
I laughed out loud when you revealed that you’d used baking soda instead of powder. At least your mouth was probably really, really clean after! LOL – the revised version looks quite tasty!
It was so bad, Jessie. And, lol, way to look on the bright side – I bet my mouth was REALLY clean… Thanks, friend!
I can’t wait to try these Marissa! I’ve never tried using cornstarch. Thanks so much for sharing the info!
Yay! I can’t wait to hear what you think. Thanks, Mary Ann!
I’ve never used baking powder, but I regularly use cornstarch, like, all the time when I make wings. I made a big batch this weekend for a family get-together and they disappeared in a flash. Girl, I believe you 😉 !!! These look super duper good and that blue cheese sauce and buffalo dip are a MUST! P.S. what part of the wing do you like best? Hubby likes the drum part and me the wing part so it works out lovely for us, lol. Awesome recipe, my friend!
So you already knew the secret! Oh man, I like the drum and wing pretty equally – I love that you and your fella have it all worked out. 😉
OMG… you make me feel so much better… and Im laughing at the memories….. I did the same thing the first time I made the recipe with baking powder, and accidentally used baking soda. My husband deserves major kudos for eating all of them, while I was like this is terrible! Im going to give your cornstarch method a try Marissa!
Michele, I relate! My husband ate them too…that baking soda flavor was epic, lol! I can’t wait to hear what you think of this method!!
Thank you for the great recipe, I adapted it a little by using drumsticks 1.5 lbs.
I used a clear glass spice jar with a holes in the top to shake on the baking powder.
I then added the bbq sauce, and followed the recipe. Mind turned out delicious
but less crispy as I used a deep baking dish. I have never tasted such tender chicken.
The benefit of course is the slow oven, it does take the oven to heat up to 425. So
allow sufficient time. It doesn’t hurt in my opinion to add another 10 minutes.
I’ve never tried this with drumsticks – great idea! 🙂
I’m trying this recipe (with drumsticks) this very minute! Just popped them in the oven. My only alteration is adding a few spices (garlic & onion powders and cayenne) to the salt/cornstarch mixture. I typically roll my eyes when someone claims to have perfected baked chicken wings but I am excited to try these drumsticks!! (The didn’t have wings at my grocery today, weird but oh well!) Thanks for sharing!
That’s great, Jennifer! I haven’t tried it with drumsticks. I think they’ll be delicious, but will need a longer cooking time.
Nope!! They were perfect using the same cook time as you posted for wings. I loved this recipe, thanks again!!
That is awesome, Jennifer! Really sweet of you to come back and let me know – now I’ve got to try it too!
This is amazing recipe! Thanks!
Thanks so much…
Do you remove from oven at temp switch?
Hi Brutus – nope, they stay in the whole time… 🙂
I made these tonight for dinner! What an awesome recipe! Thanks for sharing. My husband can’t stop talking about them. I made buffalo and garlic parm.
That’s fantastic! So kind of you to come back to let me know. 🙂
I made these before, and I’am making them right now. All I can say is WOW! So delicious! I won’t make them any other way, they come out so crispy, when adding the baking powder, Tip I let them sit in the refrigerator for a few hours before putting them in the,oven. They come out so crispy! YUMMERS! !
Awesome! I’m so glad you like them, Jo Anne!
Just made these…they turned out perfect. Thanks for sharing your recipe! I believe Super Bowl tradition has been born.
Yay! You made my day, Donna!!
Thank you @Marissa for co-hosting this great giveaway! I was contacted by Kristi and I am the winner! Yeah! I love following your blog and collecting all of these fantastic recipes. I will be stopping by often.
Congratulations, Trish! And what a sweet note, thank you!
Get outta town! I LOVE baked chicken wings! These look SO darn good!
🙂 Thanks, Kayiu!!
I also won’t deep fry in my kitchen (but mostly because I’m certain I’d accidentally stick a finger in the frying oil), so I LOVE this crispy oven-baked version you made! Thanks for sharing!
I hate frying things in my kitchen but I love the food! These wings look wonderful and I’ll never know it’s baked if you don’t mention it! Will try out the baking powder idea, sounds like a perfect solution! 🙂
Try it, Maggie! Can’t wait to hear what you think… 😉
I can’t tell you how many times I’ve mixed up baking soda and baking powder – I say we make a movement to change the names so they’re distinctly different 😛
This is such a wonderful recipe and I love that these are baked! I personally don’t mind frying food in my home (in terms of the actual act of doing it), but I do appreciate baking in terms of the health conscience part of me! And I love the blue cheese dip – gotta have blue cheese with wings!
I agree! Gotta have the blue cheese dip. 😉
These look amazing! And I don’t even really like wings!
Thank you!
Ooh, these look great! And that’s saying something, because I am not a wing person at all. 🙂 They still look great! I love the simplicity of the baking powder & salt coating.
Thanks, Eileen. I still can’t get over how easy these are to make.
Buffalo wings are always too good to resist! I love that your recipe is easy and perfect for game days!
Thanks Ashley!
Marissa, we *love*baked wings and learned the baking powder trick. Man, it works absolutely perfectly! The wings are crisp on the outside and juicy, tender on the inside. I guess I’m saying, you must know I love this recipe! Oh, and thanks so much for participating in the giveaway!
Thanks for including me, Kristi! xx
oh no!!! what a mix up! i ALWAYS double check because it’s definitely happened to me while baking! so awesome that you decided to give it another go!
crispy wings for the win!!! 😀
I’m so glad I gave it another go, once the baking soda taste had finally passed. 🙂 This will be a go-to party appetizer recipe for me from here on out – thanks for the inspiration, Stephanie!
I’ve got to give these a try! I love chicken wings and crispy baked ones are right up my alley 😀
You’ve got to try them, Lorraine! Can’t wait to hear what you think…
I’m with you – frying stuff at home is no fun. I make too much of a mess and frankly I’m not sure if I can be trusted with that much hot oil! These baked wings look perfect for game day!
Liz, I hear you! I don’t trust myself with molten hot oil – a little too accident prone I’m afraid. And on that note, if you have never read “How to Start a Grease Fire” from Pen & Palate, you must. It’s hilarious – http://www.penandpalate.net/?p=353
Marissa! Thank you for the shout out!! And OMG, I had to laugh – BAKING SODA is AWFUL!! I made that mistake too!! And every time I go to make the recipe, I hesitate and have to double check that I am to use baking POWDER not SODA. Because it really is a natural instinct to reach out for baking soda! Coating meat in powder is weird, right?? And you know what? I just made a batch yesterday and was tossing up whether to use a blue cheese or other dip, but because I was LOST in the selection of blue cheese dips out there, I ended up going in another direction – but now I can use yours!! Yay yay!!
Just one question – is the blue cheese you use the “crumbly” type (like feta) or is it slightly creamy (i.e. if you crumble it with your fingers you get it smeared on your fingers, whereas with feta you would not!) Thank you Marissa!!
Yay, I’m not alone! 🙂 On the blue cheese, the kind I used is on the creamy side – definitely gets smeared on your fingers.
Just made a batch…. Used baking soda.. . Was about to write a WTF message but realised that I am the one who didn’t read. Maybe write in parentheses “not baking soda” so no other poor soul goes through what my mouth just went through.
I made the same mistake the first time and, you’re right, just awful! Definitely try it with baking powder… 🙂
These look great for the big game day coming up. Too bad I want them today and I’m on day 1 of a 3 day cleanse. Detox and refresh! That baking powder tip is interesting, I’ve heard of cornstarch – a new must try!
Good for you, Kevin! Just two days to go. When you’re ready to try these though, I’d love to hear what you think.
Ugh, I hate frying too. I avoid wings because of it! I’m definitely making these for the superbowl! And I’m pretty excited. I can’t remember the last time I had wings!
I’d love to hear what you think, Amanda!